Email updates

Keep up to date with the latest news and content from Genome Biology and BioMed Central.

Paper report

Polymorphisms suggest mitochondrial recombination

Gilean McVean

Genome Biology 2000, 1:reports014  doi:10.1186/gb-2000-1-1-reports014

The electronic version of this article is the complete one and can be found online at: http://genomebiology.com/2000/1/1/reports/014


Received:17 December 1999
Published:17 March 2000

© 2000 BioMed Central Ltd

Significance and context

There is a persistent belief that in animals and higher plants, mitochondria are inherited from only one parent, the female. This means that different mitochondria should never be found in the same individual, and so mitochondria cannot recombine. Working from this assumption, mitochondrial sequences have become the paradigm for inferring relationships between different human groups. By looking at patterns of DNA polymorphism, Eyre-Walker et al. have provided evidence that recombination events have occurred in the evolutionary history of human mitochondria. This means that mitochondria from sperm must sometimes enter the egg at fertilization. Conclusions about human history derived from studies of mitochondrial DNA must now be reinterpreted.

Key results

The authors used published data from 29 largely complete mitochondrial sequences, taken from humans from Europe and Africa. Nucleotide positions that vary between individuals, known as segregating sites, were used to construct trees representing the relationship between sequences. If each segregating site is the result of a single mutation, and there is no recombination, then the pattern of variation describes a unique tree. If recombination occurs, however, then different parts of the sequence will have different trees. This means that if you try to construct a single tree from sequences in which there is recombination, some segregating sites will appear to be the result of several mutations. If there is an independent estimate of the mutation rate, the number of these 'homoplasies' can be used as an indicator of the extent of recombination. Eyre-Walker and colleagues show here that the number of homoplasies in the human mitochondrial trees is difficult to explain by mutation alone and argue that recombination is the most likely explanation.

Links

For a thorough description of the statistics behind the inferring of patterns of evolution from DNA sequence data see the paper Ancestral inference from gene trees by R Griffiths, available as a Postscript file. For specifics of the test used see Maynard Smith's homoplasy test.

Reporter's comments

To claim that there is recombination in human mitochondria is close to heresy. So many studies have used mitochondrial sequences to infer patterns of population history because in the absence of recombination you can build phylogenetic trees. The notion of a mitochondrial 'Eve' is even based on the assumption that there is no recombination. This paper (and another by Hagelberg and colleagues in the same volume) provide strong evidence for recombination, but the tests used here are based on the rejection of null models, and it is an open question as to whether these patterns may also be caused by poorly understood mutational processes. It would be much more satisfying to see patterns that provide a genuine footprint of recombination.

Table of links

Assumptions that are made about each paper that is the subject of a report, unless otherwise specified:
The full text and figures are available only to subscribers of the journal, but are available over the internet from the journal's website. The paper itself is abstracted by PubMed. There is no supplementary material.